UNWILLING, UNQUALIFIED, UNFORTUNATE, UNGRATEFUL

Date:

Comments:

War is often remembered in numbers—millions of lives, years of conflict, the cold arithmetic of bombs and dates. But numbers, for all their weight, rarely tell you how a war felt. For that, you have to look at something smaller. Something human. Something that fit in a young soldier’s pocket.

A lighter

Not issued with ceremony. Not meant to last beyond a tour. And yet, etched into its metal is a sentence that has outlived speeches, strategies, and slogans:
“We the unwilling, led by the unqualified, to kill the unfortunate, die for the ungrateful.”
No historian wrote that. No government approved it. It wasn’t meant for the world. It was a thought—raw, unfiltered—scratched into steel by someone who had seen enough to stop believing in neat explanations.

Fifty years on, we can debate the war endlessly—who was right, who was wrong, what was gained, what was lost. Those arguments will never quite end. But this lighter doesn’t argue. It doesn’t persuade. It simply exists, carrying a moment of clarity from someone who stood inside the storm rather than studying it from afar.
And perhaps that is the point.
Because every war leaves behind two histories. One is written in books, in treaties, in numbers that try to make sense of chaos. The other is quieter. It lives in objects, in memories, in the things people keep and don’t quite know how to explain.
This lighter belongs to that second history
The one that doesn’t shout.
The one that doesn’t resolve neatly.
The one that still flickers—long after the war itself has gone silent.

The photo is of a lighter from the American soldiers of the Vietnam War. The inscription reads, “We the unwilling, led by the unqualified to kill the unfortunate, die for the ungrateful.” Perhaps these words capture well the essence of that war through the eyes of a soldier. The essence of many wars.

CLN Policy on Comments:

CLN reserves the right to edit or not publish any comment, especially if it contains offensive or inappropriate language.

Join our WhatsApp Group for News and Article Alerts

CLICK HERE to join our WhatsApp Group

4 COMMENTS

  1. On the one hand we are confronted by such well meaning articles and on the other we see senseless screaming and shouting at IPL matches. One CANNOT MAKE SENSE of HUMAN PRIORITIES. There are small establishments closing for want if LOG, tens of thousands of civil construction workers trying to flee middle-eastern existential threats and there are cricketers irresponsibly dancing a jig with construction workers is studios – we live in a very illogical world.

  2. One is amazed by the masterminds dictating and showcasing military strategy, geopolitical manoeuvres, WhiteHouse/Pentagon insights,
    Control over the Nuclear button – the mind boggles!

    If there has been relative stability against war mongering after the WW II, it is the earnest dialogue, diplomacy and detente amongst world leaders behind closed doors and sans the media. This has sadly STOPPED and the new mantra of sabre rattling and raking in the spoils of the war that has taken centre stage attention.

    All wars have ironically demonstrated that the people initiating the aggression do not ever have to face the physical consequences first hand.

    HOPE BETTER SENSE PREVAILS – NOTHING ELSE MATTERS.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

The maximum upload file size: 100 MB. You can upload: image, audio, video, document, spreadsheet, interactive, text, archive, code, other. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop files here

Recent Comments

Subscribe to CLN Print Edition

spot_img

More Posts
Related

Man smart, smartphones smarter

Life was much easier when Apple and Blackberry were...

THE SCOURGE OF PLAGIARISM

Plagiarism is the representation of another person's language, thoughts, ideas,...

Going Bananas

Quite literally, this is a story that moved from...

Edamyaar Ondh 2026 – Kodava New Year

Rice is central to Kodava culture and figures prominently...