As Karnataka celebrates Rajyotsava today, marking the formation of the unified Kannada-speaking state under the States Reorganisation Act on November 1, 1956, it is interesting to see a few Kodavas on social media lamenting the loss of the erstwhile Coorg State.
While the sentiment may be understandable, what purpose does it serve to keep crying over spilt milk? The merger of Coorg with the newly reorganised Mysore State was a historical event that took place seven decades ago.
Have those who nostalgically remember Kodagu’s lost statehood ever paused to ponder this uncomfortable question?
Who Betrayed the Trust?
When Coorg (Kodagu) State was merged with Mysore State in 1956, it had its own elected Legislative Assembly, a majority of whose members were Coorgs (Kodavas), and a Kodava Chief Minister at the helm. Yet, the overwhelming majority of its legislators voted in favour of the merger.
Even Pandyanda Belliappa, one of the most vociferous opponents of the merger, ultimately voted in its favour.
Why did they not do more to preserve Kodagu’s separate statehood? Was the loss of its political identity inevitable, or did its own elected representatives fail to defend it with sufficient determination? Where was the effective leadership? What became of the so-called educated aristocracy that was expected to safeguard Kodagu’s political future?
Before lamenting the loss of statehood today, perhaps we should critically examine the decisions of those who were entrusted with preserving it then.
Repeatedly revisiting that decision will not change the present reality. Perhaps it is time to move beyond nostalgia and focus on the issues that genuinely threaten the future of Kodagu and its people.
Successive Karnataka governments have not fundamentally altered the cultural character of Kodagu. In fact, the region has retained much of its distinctive identity, traditions and customs. The argument that Kodagu has been neglected in terms of development also deserves closer scrutiny. Several native legislators have represented the district over the decades. Have we, as voters, consistently held them accountable for their promises and performance? Development is not merely the responsibility of the government; elected representatives must be questioned, and the public must demand results.
More importantly, there are far more pressing concerns that deserve the attention of the Kodava community. The protection of Jamma lands, rivers & foresssts, the preservation of our language, customs, traditions and cultural institutions, and the transmission of our heritage to the next generation should be at the forefront of our concerns.
What good is lamenting the loss of a state when we are unable to safeguard the very cultural and ancestral foundations that define our identity? Jamma land ownership and its associated rights, the gradual erosion of traditional practices, the declining use of the Kodava language among younger generations, and, perhaps most importantly, the lack of sustained efforts to practise and uphold our ancestral way of life are challenges that cannot be postponed. Culture cannot survive merely through festivals, ceremonial displays or occasional expressions of pride and oneupmanship. It must be lived, practised and passed on to the next generation, as our ancestors did, through customs, values and traditions.
Instead of spending our energies debating a political arrangement that cannot be reversed, perhaps we should ask ourselves a more uncomfortable question: What are we doing today to ensure that Kodagu’s identity, culture, language and heritage survive for generations to come?
A community’s strength is not measured by whether it has a state of its own, but by its ability to preserve its identity, protect its heritage and pass on its legacy.
This Karnataka Rajyotsava, perhaps it is time for the Kodavas to look forward rather than continually look back.




Well written article.
This is a complex issue with no answer that will be acceptable to everyone. It is a known fact that Coorg was amongst the rare States that delivered a positive surplus in the budget year-after-year. Zero corruption, excellent discipline with a sense of purpose. Could we have sustained this track record in the following years? Of course the obvious criticism against this view would be – if we were an independent state we could have retained this performance through the years.
First and foremost, Kodagu’s political leadership has been found “wanting” at least for over five decades. Even if we had retained our separate statehood, our political leaders would always be looking for the ruling from their High Command.
That leads me to the next natural statement that we should have strong apolitical community leaders. The jury is out – our leadership remains fragmented with no unified vision to protect the future of Kodagu and the Kodava identity. This needs to change. Jabhoomi is one Organisation that consistently maintains that Community Organisations should remain apolitical.
Everyone is aware that Coorg as an Independent State are land locked. Unlike the Bunts of Tulunad, (who for the record lost their land when The Karnataka Land Reforms Act 1974 was promulgated – while we mostly escaped due to a fortunate interpretation of the Act) rolled up their sleeves and migrated to Mumbai, Bangalore, the Middle East in search of jobs and eventually owned the restaurants chains in these places. They reinvested their earnings and established iconic institutions of Higher Education, Healthcare, Hospitality Groups and MSMEs to prosper, without looking back in a matter of 50 years.
In contrast, the planters did very little to add value to our primary crops of Coffee, Pepper, Cardamom and so on with unorganized HomeStays providing an easy source of alternate income. Those who went after higher education (often by selling their properties) emigrated for salaried jobs in cities loosing their footholds in Kodagu. As a consequence the general lament of no opportunities in Kodagu became the norm with a false sense of security/refuge in larger cities/state. Truth be told, there were many families who aspirationally moved to Mysore pre 1956 seeking employment with the Government and Public Sectors.
So there is no one clear answer – other than hard work, innovation, humility of dignity of labour and passion to do better. The sense of “entitlement” is best put to rest with a focus on retaining one’s inherited land, responsible high quality Homestays and value adding work (take a leaf out of the immigrant communities who seem to be prospering at our expense).
As a glaring example let us take the functioning and benefits delivered by the premier Community Institution Akhila Kodava Samaja which was set up in 1942. It would be most relevant to understand the reasons for the underperformance of this premier institution which was wisely set up to uphold the interests of Kodavas and the future of Kodagu.
Can we please talk about 1952 instead of 1956. If the Congress had been united in 1952 “the only window to keep Coorg separate”(according to Pandyanda Belliappa)..the events in 1956 would not have happened. I am definitely one of those who is still crying over spilt milk not because I am Pandyanda Belliappa’s grand daughter, but because the state of Kodagu after merger and even today is not something to be celebrated. If Karnataka had treated Kodagu right and given good administration..one didn’t have to cry over spilt milk.
It is almost seven decades since the erstwhile C-State Kodagu merged with the larger Karnataka State. Rather than dwelling on historical developments, it is time to focus on improving the economic well-being of the people of Kodagu. Our traditions and culture can flourish when people’s basic livelihood needs are secured.
In my opinion, preserving Kodava culture requires action on several fronts:
1. Culture Begins at Home
* Kodava culture is not merely about wearing traditional attire or participating in festivals. It is rooted in respecting women and elders, practising generosity, and standing by fellow Kodavas during difficult times.
* Speaking our mother tongue, Kodava Takk, and passing it on to the next generation are fundamental to preserving our identity.
2. Economic Well-being and Changing Demographics
* Economic disparities and demographic changes are reshaping Kodagu’s social and economic landscape.
* Tourism is creating new livelihood opportunities, particularly for small farmers, and deserves to be developed responsibly.
* We must recognise the changing economic realities of Kodagu’s predominantly small and marginal landholders.
3. Protecting Our Agricultural and Ecological Heritage
* The traditional Jamma landownership system significantly shaped Kodagu’s paddy fields and bane lands.
* The reported decline in Jamma wetlands to nearly 25% of their 1956 extent and livestock populations to approximately 20% of earlier levels should be a matter of serious concern.
* Conversion of traditional paddy wetlands into coffee plantations has affected natural rainwater retention, groundwater recharge, soil fertility and ecological balance.
* Protecting water bodies, restoring paddy cultivation wherever feasible and conserving traditional grazing lands must become priorities.
4. Make Our Land Productive Again
* Encourage planting more fruit-bearing trees, growing vegetables and adopting compost-based organic farming.
* Instead of dedicating 10–12 hours daily to the organisations and businesses of others, let us also devote meaningful working hours to improving our own agricultural holdings.
* Sustainable agriculture and responsible tourism can together strengthen Kodagu’s rural economy.
5. Elders Must Lead by Example
* We cannot expect younger generations to respect and practise traditions that we ourselves neglect.
* Elders must become role models by learning, reading, practising and communicating our history, language and customs.
* We should move beyond social and club-centred activities and create opportunities for meaningful cultural participation in everyday life.
6. Collective Responsibility, Not Finger-pointing
* We must abandon the mindset that someone else, particularly community organisations, will restore and preserve Kodava culture.
* Community organisations certainly have an important role, but the primary responsibility rests with every Kodava family and individual.
* Those who preach cultural preservation must first practise it themselves.
My personal opinion: We elders must introspect before pointing fingers at the younger generation or community organisations. We cannot preserve Kodava identity through speeches, attire and celebrations alone. It requires protecting our language, respecting our values, strengthening our rural economy, conserving our natural resources and practising our traditions in everyday life.
The responsibility to preserve Kodava culture begins with us. Let us become the change we wish to see in the next generation
A Hard hitting and courageous article that refuses to simply blame History and move on. It asks kodagu to look into the mirror and confront the uncomfortable truth.
If kodagu had its own elected Assembly , with kodavas forming the majority and a kodava chief minister at the helm , why was its separate political- identity surrendered? Where was the leadership? Where was the determination to protect kodagu’s future?
We cannot change what happened in 1956. But we cannot certainly learn from it. People who do not critically examine their past may fail to protect their future.
This is a balanced article written with a practical way forward. Some of Kodagu’s leaders indulge in questioning the merger when it is a lost cause. Also, there will be too many skeletons that will come out of the cupboard that will not make pleasant reading and not serving any practical purpose. Field Marshal Cariappa Ajja always advised against this move but his ability to politically influence the dispensation at that point in time was limited.
I endorse Machaiah’s views in advising the people to look ahead. There are many serious issues that confront the future of Kodagu and the identity of Kodavas – address this with collective thought and determined action.
The demographic change in the past two decades should be of utmost concern; so also unregulated and irresponsible tourism with the environment simply not able to cope with the uncontrolled volumes. Look at what has happened in Wayanad, Ooty and Coonoor – waiting to happen in Kodagu.
Woefully inadequate infrastructure, lack of entrepreneurial support to add value to primary crops, rampant desecration of the environment, facilities for higher education and much improved healthcare facilities, incentives for wetland cultivation (critical for maintaining the water table), longer term resolution of human animal conflict by management the forests in a more transparent and effective manner…. These are some of the obvious high priority actionable items that need to be addressed.
Is there a common ground of priorities for our political and community leaders; also, the district administration? Is there a transparent periodic review (and not a manifesto of achievements for political gain) of “objectives vs execution” with accountability?
The time to act is NOW.
Very true, Kodavas themselves ignore our traditions and cry saying we are losing our culture. Also, Please write an article on the reasons why kodagu decided to merge with the mysuru state.
Lekhan, there is a book written on it, which has a lot of information on that period.
Rise and Fall of the Coorg State. – By: P T Bopanna. You should read it.
https://www.amazon.in/Rise-Fall-Coorg-State-Karnatakas/dp/9385741071